Evaluation the practicability of Cord
formation of MGIT positive smears for Presumptive Identification of
Mycobacterium tuberculosis
Shu-Fen Jan, Jenn-fuh Leu, Pen-Tsai Weng,
I-Shan Wu, Yi-Tien Chen,
Rui-Fu-Shi Medical Laboratory, Taichung40715,
Taiwan
Background: More than 50%
Mycobacterium isolates are Non-tuberculous Mycobacterium (NTM) in most
mycobacterial laboratories in Taiwan. Species identification of
mycobacterium requires the use of time-consuming conventional biochemical
methods, or more rapid molecular techniques that are expensive and require
special instrument. Cord factor is known of the specific toxic factor of
Mycobacterium tuberculosis (MTB). Most of MTB can be examined the cord
formation in acid fast staining smears (AFS) of direct specimens or liquid
cultures, and on young culture colonies of Middlebrook 7H10 or 7H11. The
aim of this study is to evaluate the practicability of microscopic
examination of the cord formation in BACTEC MGIT (Becton Dickinson
Diagnostic Systems, Sparks, MD) culture positive smears for presumptive
identification of MTB.
Method: A total 522 acid fast
positive smears of MGIT cultures were collected on October 2007. Each of
smears was examined the microscopic morphology, including cord,
pseudo-cord, needle, dot, short, ladder. Species identification of all
mycobacterium isolates were undertaken by conventional biochemical
techniques. The sensitivity and the specificity of cord formation for
discriminating MTB from NTM were calculated by using conventional
biochemical techniques as standard.
Result: Of 522
MGIT-positive cultures, 250 were identified as MTB and one mixed with MTB
and M. avian complex(MAC) by conventional method. The remaining 271
cultures were NTM, including 112 MAC, 21 M. kansasii, 39 M. abscessus, 18
M. fortuitum group, 7 M. gordonae, 6 M. scrofulaceum, 2 M. mucogenicum, 3
M. marinum, 58 unidentified NTM, 3 mixed with two NTM species, 2 mixed
with MAC and unidentified NTM. Of 251 MTB isolates, 249 were found cord
formation, including the MTB and MAC mixed culture. OF 271 NTM cultures,
only one was found cord formation, and 21 were found pseudo-cord. The
overall sensitivity and specificity of the cord formation was calculated
to be 99.2% and 99.6%.
Conclusion: Our results
manifested that the usefulness of the cording morphology as a rapid and
simple microscopic examination test for presumptive identification of MTB
in MGIT-positive cultures with high sensitivity and high specificity.
Because pseudo-cord might be confounded as the cord formation of MTB,
examiner must have high experience for microscopic morphologies of
mycobacteria. We suggest that the cord formation can only be employed as a
rapid screening examination for MTB. It still required further
confirmation by other test techniques.
Key words: Mycobacterium tuberculosis,
cord formation, MGIT, microscopic examination
Contact person email: jeff_lu@sancordon.com.tw